When buying a GmbH, the purchaser also buys its tax history. Whatever the tax audit may claim years later for the period before the sale hits the company – and thus, economically, the buyer. The tax clause allocates this risk around the effective date of the acquisition. This article deals with its key points.
Why the tax clause is a chapter of its own
In a share deal, the company changes hands, not its liabilities. Taxes for the years before the sale continue to be owed by the company. The assessment period is four years, and a tax audit suspends its expiry (Section 171 (4) of the German Fiscal Code, AO). A back-tax claim for the year before the sale can therefore come six or seven years after closing. Statutory warranty law does not help the buyer here, because a tax back payment is not a defect in the purchased share. Without a contractual provision, the buyer bears the claim.
The agreement has two instruments for this. The tax warranty is a representation by the seller that as a rule applies regardless of fault: returns have been filed, taxes paid, no tax audit is pending, there are no hidden profit distributions. A breach leads to damages, subject to the usual defences that the agreement provides by analogy with warranty law. The tax indemnity pursues a different aim: the seller bears the taxes for the period up to the effective date, regardless of whether they knew or could have known of them. The tax indemnity is necessary and customary because tax consequences and closing do not run in parallel. The tax warranty supplements it for risks that have come to light in due diligence. In an asset deal, the situation is different, but not risk-free for the purchaser: they are liable for operating taxes for the last year before the transfer (Section 75 AO), and this also requires an indemnity.
What matters in the tax clause
1. Definition of taxes and effective date
The term “taxes” must be defined; otherwise Section 3 AO applies, which only covers interest, late-payment and late-filing surcharges if the agreement refers to Section 3 (4) AO. A broad definition is customary: taxes and ancillary tax payments, social security contributions, foreign levies and liability amounts for which the company is held liable as a secondary debtor. The effective date determines which taxes are attributable to whom. In a sale with closing accounts, it is the day of closing; with the so-called locked-box mechanism, it is the economic transfer date in the past. For taxes whose period spans the effective date, for example corporation tax on a sale during the year, the clause sets the split: by interim accounts or pro rata temporis. Transaction taxes on the purchase itself do not belong in the indemnity but in a separate provision: real estate transfer tax on a share deal involving real estate is owed by the purchaser and/or the company itself, depending on the circumstances, and the agreement determines who bears it economically. VAT in an asset deal is dealt with by a clause on the transfer of a going concern (Section 1 (1a) of the German VAT Act, UStG) with a right to claim back if the tax office treats the transfer as taxable.
2. Credits: provisions, refunds, timing differences
The tax indemnity should not put the buyer in a better position than they would be in without it. Three deductions are therefore typical. First: tax provisions and liabilities that appear in the closing or locked-box accounts and have already reduced the purchase price are credited. Second: tax refunds for the period up to the effective date that were not recognised in the accounts are due to the seller, often set off against the seller’s indemnity obligation. Third: tax benefits that the back-tax claim generates for the buyer are offset.
An example of the third point: for the year 2023, the tax audit subsequently capitalises production costs of €300,000 that the company had booked as expenses. The 2023 profit rises; at a tax rate of around 30 %, the back payment is around €90,000. The seller bears this tax via the tax indemnity. However, the capitalised costs are depreciated over ten years: from 2024 to 2033, profit falls by €30,000 a year and tax by around €9,000 a year. The buyer receives this benefit. Without a credit clause, the seller pays €90,000 and the buyer saves the same amount over the years.
The requirement for the clause: benefits from a so-called timing difference (Phasenverschiebung) are credited against the indemnity. The point of dispute is how. The seller wants to offset the benefit immediately on a discounted basis; the buyer only once it has actually been realised. There is also often disagreement about the length of the crediting period and the reference point within the acquired company.
3. Procedure: information, cooperation, conduct of proceedings
After closing, the buyer controls the company and the seller pays the historic taxes. The procedural part of the clause governs this divergence of control and cost. The buyer informs the seller without undue delay of audit orders, audit findings and assessments concerning periods up to the effective date. The seller is given the right to take part in audits, to conduct objections and court actions at their own expense and to determine submissions. Any settlement with the tax office on historic periods, for example at the final audit meeting, requires the seller’s consent. If the buyer breaches these obligations, the buyer loses the indemnity claim to the extent that the breach has affected the back-tax claim.
In addition, there are conduct obligations for the buyer for the period after closing: no amendment of tax returns or balance sheet items for historic years without the seller’s consent, no reorganisations with retroactive tax effect on periods before the effective date, no applications that burden historic years. In return, the seller undertakes to cooperate on tax returns for historic years and to hand over documents.
4. Limitation, caps and knowledge
The indemnity needs its own limitation rule, because the agreement’s general warranty period of twelve or eighteen months usually expires before the tax audit has begun. Monetary limits are usually negotiated separately for the indemnity: the deductible (so-called basket) and the de minimis threshold that apply to warranties do not suit an indemnity for quantified back-tax claims.
The buyer’s knowledge from due diligence can exclude warranty claims, but not indemnity claims: the indemnity is intended precisely for known or expected tax consequences that the buyer does not want to, or cannot, price into the purchase price.
5. Payment route and tax consequences of the payment
The clause determines to whom the seller pays: to the buyer or directly to the company in which the tax arises. Both have tax consequences. A payment to the buyer is typically a subsequent reduction of the purchase price: the seller’s capital gain falls retroactively, and the buyer’s acquisition cost of the shares falls. A payment to the company brings the liquidity to where it is needed. According to the prevailing view, it is treated at the buyer’s level as a purchase price reduction and at the same time as a hidden contribution to the company, i.e. not as income of the company. Because the tax authorities may take a different view in individual cases, the tax clause often provides for a gross-up: if the indemnity payment itself triggers tax, it is increased by that amount.
The Federal Fiscal Court (Bundesfinanzhof) has ruled that a share transfer can be unwound if the parties expressly discussed the tax consequences before concluding the agreement and the transaction “stands or falls” with that assumption (judgment of 9 May 2025, IX R 4/23). The capital gain then lapses retroactively. The standard is strict, however: a unilateral misconception is not enough, and the tax consequence must have been fundamental for both sides. For company acquisitions, this does not create a safety net but a requirement: tax consequences on which the transaction depends belong in the agreement as a condition, right of withdrawal or adjustment clause. The doctrine of frustration of contract is no substitute.
Tax clause: drafting and negotiating
We draft and negotiate tax clauses for buyers and sellers: definition of taxes and effective date, credits, procedural rights, limitation and payment route, aligned with the agreement’s purchase price mechanism. For sellers, we prepare the tax side with our Vendor Due Diligence Light, so that known risks are on the table before the negotiation and are not merely left to the indemnity. For the review of a tax clause put to you, we offer you a fixed price agreed before work begins. Because law and tax are under one roof with us, one team drafts the clause and calculates its effect.
Talk to us.
Frequently asked questions
The warranty is a representation about the past. Its breach triggers damages. The indemnity is an assumption of the taxes up to the effective date regardless of fault, in order to capture the economic effects of the transfer correctly.
The company, i.e. the buyer, is the tax office’s point of contact. The seller bears the back-tax claim. The tax clause therefore governs how both sides are informed, cooperate and decide on objections or settlements.
As a rule, yes. Refunds for the period up to the effective date that were not already taken into account in the accounts are due to the seller. Back payments and refunds are often set off against each other.
This article provides a general overview for information purposes only and does not replace advice on individual cases. As of: November 2026.