Corporate Law & M&A

The GmbH’s articles of association: five key clauses with tax effects

The articles of association govern who has a say, who receives how much from the GmbH and what happens when a shareholder leaves. Many of these clauses have a tax effect: they trigger gift tax, secure or jeopardise relief on succession and determine whether a distribution is recognised as such for tax purposes. This article deals with five points in a GmbH’s articles of association and their tax consequences.

Why the articles of association are a tax document

German gift tax law ties in with events laid down in the articles of association, without any shareholder intending to give anything away. If a shareholder leaves in return for a severance payment below the value of their share, the difference is deemed a gift to the remaining shareholders (Section 7 (7) of the German Inheritance and Gift Tax Act, ErbStG). If one shareholder pays more into the company than the others, the increase in value of their shares is deemed a gift to them (Section 7 (8) ErbStG). Both provisions create a fictitious gift. It does not matter whether those involved were aware that no consideration was given or intended to enrich anyone. All that counts is the comparison of values.

The relief for business assets, which waives up to 100 % of the tax on the transfer of GmbH shares (Sections 13a and 13b ErbStG), does not help in these cases. According to case law and the tax authorities, it applies to the acquisition of shares, not to an increase in the value of existing shares. That makes these clauses expensive: the tax hits shareholders who receive no money, only the share or an increase in the value of their shares, from which the tax cannot be paid. And it hits them without the relief that would be available on an intended transfer.

What matters in the articles of association

1. The severance clause

Under corporate law, the articles may limit the severance payment to a departing shareholder, for example to book value or a discount on market value, in order to protect the company from an excessive outflow of liquidity. The limit is gross disproportion: a clause that is grossly disproportionate to the actual value at the time it is agreed is contrary to public policy and void. If the disproportion only arises later, for example because the business has grown, the clause remains valid and the courts adjust the severance payment in good faith (settled case law of the Federal Court of Justice, Bundesgerichtshof). For tax purposes, the problem begins earlier. Any severance payment below fair market value, which the tax office generally determines using the so-called simplified capitalised earnings method, triggers the fictitious gift – even if all shareholders agreed to the redemption at a discount (Federal Fiscal Court, Bundesfinanzhof, judgment of 17 November 2021, II R 21/20).

An example: three unrelated shareholders each hold a third of a GmbH. A leaves. The market value of A’s share is €1,000,000; the book value clause results in €300,000. The difference of €700,000 is deemed a gift to B and C, €350,000 each. In tax class III, which applies between unrelated persons, after deducting the €20,000 allowance, around €100,000 in gift tax arises per shareholder, around €200,000 in total – without B and C having received any money. A additionally pays tax on the gain from the severance payment under the partial income method (Section 17 of the German Income Tax Act, EStG).

The requirement for the clause: the severance payment should be based on market value, with a discount that can be justified commercially and, where appropriate, an instalment arrangement that protects the company’s liquidity. The commercial justification supports the clause under corporate law. It does not help for tax purposes: Section 7 (7) ErbStG does not ask about the reason for leaving, only about the difference between value and severance payment. If a lower severance payment is therefore agreed deliberately, for example in the event that a shareholder is excluded for good cause (a so-called bad leaver clause), gift tax must be factored into the overall calculation. The same applies to the GmbH acquiring its own shares below value: here, too, the increase in value of the other shares is deemed a gift (Section 7 (8) ErbStG).

Update

The Federal Fiscal Court has confirmed that the fictitious gift on the acquisition of own shares does not require any subjective element: neither awareness that no consideration was given nor an intention to enrich is necessary (judgment of 23 September 2025, II R 19/24). In the case decided, a shareholder had sold their share to the GmbH. The tax office assessed gift tax against the remaining shareholder. All that matters is whether the value of the remaining shares has increased. There is no increase in value, however, if performance and consideration were regarded as balanced on arm’s-length terms. The valuation at the time of the transfer should therefore be documented.

2. The succession clause on death

GmbH shares can be inherited. The articles may provide that the share of a deceased shareholder is redeemed or must be assigned to the other shareholders or to specific successors. For tax purposes, this has two sides. If a successor inherits the share and remains a shareholder, the relief for business assets can apply. This requires that the deceased held more than 25 % or that their shares were bound in a pool (see point 5). If the share is redeemed after the death or the heir must assign it, the heir receives the severance payment. The relief may then lapse retroactively: the heir gives up the share in return for severance within the retention period, which according to the prevailing view is treated like a sale (Section 13a (6) sentence 1 no. 4 ErbStG). Subsequent taxation can be avoided if the severance payment is reinvested in qualifying assets within six months. If the severance payment is also below value, the difference is deemed an acquisition on death by the remaining shareholders (Section 3 (1) no. 2 ErbStG).

The requirement for the clause: the articles should specify which successors may receive and keep the share – for example descendants and spouses – and provide for all others an obligation to assign with a severance payment that corresponds to the severance clause in point 1. In practice, the will and the articles of association must fit together. A will that leaves the share to a person who cannot become a shareholder under the articles cannot bring about the desired succession.

3. Profit allocation

By law, profit is allocated in proportion to the shares. The articles may permit a different yardstick (Section 29 (3) of the German Limited Liability Companies Act, GmbHG), and they may contain an opening clause under which the shareholders resolve a different allocation for an individual year. For tax purposes, such a so-called disproportionate profit distribution is recognised if it is effective under civil law. The Federal Fiscal Court even recognises a resolution that departs from the articles for a single year if all shareholders agree and the resolution is not challenged (judgment of 28 September 2022, VIII R 20/20). The tax authorities have followed this in all open cases since the Federal Ministry of Finance circular of 4 September 2024, but require unanimity for a resolution departing from the articles and an effect limited to the individual distribution.

The risk lies in the justification. If one shareholder receives more profit than their share corresponds to, the tax office asks why. If there is no business reason, such as greater work input or a preferential position, the excess may be a gift from the other shareholders. For shareholders who are also managing directors, it may be treated as a hidden profit distribution. The requirement for the clause: the safe route is the opening clause in the articles, before it is needed. Without it, the unanimous resolution for the individual case remains, with unanimity as a requirement and without lasting effect. In both cases, the different resolution should state its reason.

4. Contributions and capital measures

If one shareholder voluntarily pays into the capital reserve without the others doing likewise, the value of all shares rises, including the shares of the other shareholders. As a rule, the contribution to the GmbH is not allocated to the shareholder. This increase in value is deemed a gift from the contributor to the others (Section 7 (8) ErbStG). The same happens if a shareholder sells land to the GmbH below value or waives a claim against it. The Federal Fiscal Court limits the tax to the value of the contribution and requires proof that the shares have actually increased in value (judgment of 10 April 2024, II R 22/21). The relief for business assets does not apply here.

The requirement for the articles: if one shareholder alone is to provide additional funding, the contribution is allocated to them – through a capital increase in which only they take up new shares, or through a shareholder-specific reserve that is due to them on distribution and departure. The articles must permit such an allocation, and the severance clause must take it into account.

5. Transfer restrictions and pooling

The articles usually make the transfer of shares subject to the consent of the shareholders (so-called restriction on transferability, Vinkulierung). For tax purposes, this restriction becomes a tool: to obtain relief from inheritance and gift tax, the transferor must hold more than 25 % of the GmbH. Smaller shareholdings are counted together if the shareholders have undertaken to dispose of their shares only uniformly or to transfer them only to members of the pool, and to exercise their voting rights uniformly (Section 13b (1) no. 3 ErbStG).

The requirement: the restriction on disposal and the voting agreement must exist at the time of the transfer, in writing and in a verifiable form. The pooling agreement can be contained in the articles or in a separate contract. Both must fit together, however, because articles that allow free transfer contradict the pooling. In family companies with several family branches, the pooling often decides whether relief is granted.

Articles of association and tax: review in advance

We review existing articles of association for these five and further points and their tax consequences, and draft severance, succession and profit allocation clauses so that corporate law and tax law fit together. For new incorporations, the tax review of the articles is part of our GmbH Formation Package. For existing companies, we offer the review and adjustment at a fixed price agreed before work begins. Because law and tax are under one roof with us, one team drafts the clause and calculates its tax consequences.

Frequently asked questions

Under corporate law, generally yes, as long as there is no gross disproportion to market value. For tax purposes, the difference between market value and severance payment on departure is deemed a gift to the remaining shareholders, without relief for business assets.

This article provides a general overview for information purposes only and does not replace advice on individual cases. As of: November 2026.

Would you like us to assess your situation?

Briefly describe your matter. We will get back to you within one business day with an initial assessment.