Tax

Salary, bonus, pension commitment: how shareholder-managing directors of a GmbH avoid hidden profit distributions

The pay of a shareholder-managing director is one of the standard focus areas of every tax audit. The review takes place on two levels: whether the amount is appropriate and whether the agreement holds up formally. Both are decided years before an auditor asks about them — and can no longer be corrected afterwards.

The tax office knows: you are negotiating with yourself.

As a shareholder-managing director, you sit on both sides of the table: you decide on your salary, you sign your service agreement, you set your bonus. Under civil law, that is permissible. For tax purposes, however, the tax authorities first measure each of these agreements against one question: would the GmbH have agreed the same with an external managing director?

If the answer is “no”, there is a hidden profit distribution (verdeckte Gewinnausschüttung, Section 8 (3) sentence 2 of the German Corporation Tax Act, KStG).

If you are the controlling shareholder, as a rule with more than 50 % of the voting rights, a second level is added: agreements between you and the company must be concluded in advance, clearly worded, effective under civil law and actually performed as written on paper. If any one of these is missing, it does not help that the amount of the pay was appropriate.

For the tax office, this second level is the easier one: whether a resolution exists and how it is dated can be established beyond doubt. Whether pay is appropriate, by contrast, remains a matter of judgement. Your pay, however, has to hold up on both levels.

What it costs

A hidden profit distribution is taxed like an open one: payments are not deductible as business expenses at the level of the GmbH and are investment income for you as the shareholder.

An example: the sole shareholder-managing director receives total pay of €320,000. The subsequent tax audit finds that €240,000 would have been appropriate. The difference of €80,000 per year is a hidden profit distribution — €240,000 in total over a period of three years.

At the level of the GmbH, this amount is added back to profit. The hidden profit distribution is a use of taxed profit, not a business expense. This results in around 30 % corporation tax and trade tax, here €72,000. At your personal level there is an offsetting effect, because employment income becomes investment income — this relieves you by up to €50,600. On balance, at least around €21,000 in additional tax remains, plus interest.

That is the favourable case. Two constellations are less pleasant. If your personal tax rate is lower, the relief at the personal level is smaller, while the burden at the GmbH stays the same. And if no money has flowed at all — for example with a pension commitment that is not recognised —, the GmbH pays tax on a profit it never earned and that you never received.

The amount: the total package is reviewed

This is not about the figure on the payslip, but about everything the GmbH grants you for your work: fixed salary, bonus, company car, insurance and the annual expense of the pension commitment. Anyone who sets a cautious fixed salary and receives a generous pension commitment alongside it has gained nothing.

The yardsticks are the nature and scope of your work, the earnings situation of the GmbH and what comparable companies pay. In practice, however, the most important point is a different one: the GmbH must retain an appropriate profit. An equal split of the profit before managing director pay is often used as a guide. That is not a fixed limit — but anyone who departs from it should be able to explain why.

A typical mistake: the service agreement often dates back to the year of incorporation and has not been touched since. The yardstick is not what you would have negotiated for yourself, but what a prudent and diligent manager of the GmbH would have agreed. It becomes critical when earnings decline and pay stays the same: what was appropriate at incorporation can drain the profit years later.

Bonus as an audit focus

Four points are decisive:

  • Ratio to fixed salary: As a rule of thumb, no more than 25 % of total pay should be variable. That is not a rigid limit, however — anyone above it needs business reasons documented in writing.
  • Ratio to profit: The bonus should not exceed half of the annual profit.
  • Basis of assessment: “20 % of annual profit” is not a usable basis. Before or after tax? Before or after deducting the bonus itself? With or without loss carryforward? If the clause leaves room for interpretation, there is no clear agreement — and for a controlling shareholder-managing director, that alone is enough for a hidden profit distribution.
  • Timing: A bonus is earned over the whole year. If the bonus for 2026 is only agreed in May 2026, five twelfths are a hidden profit distribution because there was no prior agreement. It must be concluded before the start of the financial year for which the bonus is paid.

It is important to note that turnover-based bonuses are only recognised in exceptional cases, for example during a start-up phase — and then only for a limited period and amount.

Pension commitments: the most expensive mistake

Mistakes involving pension commitments surface last. By then, provisions have usually been built up over years. If the tax office does not recognise the commitment, the correction comes all at once. In addition to the statutory requirements, the tax authorities independently examine whether the pension commitment is at arm’s length: for a controlling shareholder-managing director, at least ten years must lie between the commitment and retirement. A commitment immediately after taking office or shortly after incorporation is not at arm’s length either. Together with the statutory pension, the benefits should not significantly exceed around 75 % of the last active pay.

Update

In 2025, the Federal Fiscal Court (Bundesfinanzhof) ruled that for a commitment financed exclusively through deferred compensation, the criteria of earnability and probationary period do not apply (judgments of 19 November 2025, I R 50/22, and of 17 December 2025, I R 4/23). This leeway only exists, however, as long as the GmbH does not assume any financing risk of its own.

Always keep in mind: a pension commitment outlives your time as managing director. Prospective buyers do not want it. The obvious way out is very expensive: waiving a valuable entitlement triggers employment income for you without any money flowing. If a sale or succession is realistic in the coming years, you should think early about how to deal with pension commitments.

Five questions for today

  1. Is your entire pay agreed in writing — and before the start of the year in which it is earned?
  2. Is there a shareholder resolution on your service agreement, and are you permitted to conclude transactions with your company (exemption from Section 181 of the German Civil Code, BGB)?
  3. How is the basis of assessment for your bonus defined — is it sufficiently specific?
  4. Is what is written on paper actually put into practice?
  5. Is there a pension commitment — and when was it last reviewed?

If you hesitate on more than one question, we recommend taking a look at your documents.

No retroactive correction

Retroactive repair is not possible: for tax purposes, a prohibition on retroactivity applies. Even a tax clause in the articles of association requiring excessive pay to be repaid does not eliminate the hidden profit distribution. For tax purposes, the repayment merely constitutes a separate capital contribution; the tax burden remains.

What helps is correcting things going forward, in good time before the start of the next financial year, and with robust documentation of appropriateness. This is the best way to pre-empt questions in a tax audit.

Managing Director Remuneration Check

We review your service agreement, including the bonus arrangement, pension commitments, benefits in kind and resolutions — for appropriateness and for the formal requirements that apply to controlling shareholder-managing directors.

You receive an audit report with a concrete risk assessment, documentation of appropriateness that will stand up to a tax audit, and drafting proposals for the points that need to be adjusted. We offer you a fixed price agreed before work begins. Because law and tax are under one roof with us, one team reviews both sides.

Managing Director Remuneration Check

Fixed price, agreed before work begins.

To the Managing Director Remuneration Check →

Frequently asked questions

There is no fixed upper limit. What matters is the total package compared with what an external managing director would receive in a comparable company. The GmbH must retain an appropriate residual profit.

This article provides a general overview for information purposes only and does not replace advice on individual cases. As of: November 2026.

Would you like us to assess your situation?

Briefly describe your matter. We will get back to you within one business day with an initial assessment.