Orders decline, margins come under pressure, a site is permanently too expensive or functions are to be centralised. For management, the question of personnel costs then quickly arises. The answer does not have to be “dismissal” straight away, however. Businesses have a whole range of instruments for adapting staffing structures to a changed organisation.
The sequence is decisive. Anyone who hastily prepares individual dismissals can close off later options or trigger unnecessary costs and legal disputes. Good restructuring therefore does not begin with the notice of dismissal but with the question: what does the future target organisation look like, which jobs disappear as a result, and with which instrument can this target state be achieved in a legally secure and economic way?
Good restructuring does not begin with the dismissal, but with defining the target organisation.
Restructuring begins with the target picture
A workforce reduction should not be planned starting from the individual employee. The starting point is the business decision: which functions will still be needed in future? Which activities will disappear, be merged, relocated or outsourced? Only once the future organisation has been determined can it be established in a legally robust way which employment opportunities actually disappear.
For redundancy dismissals, the employer must be able to show comprehensibly which business decision was taken and how it affects the need for employees. At the same time, other employment opportunities must be examined. Vacant positions in the establishment or in other establishments of the same company, as well as employment opportunities after reasonable retraining, further training or under changed working conditions, may be particularly relevant.
The basic logic is therefore:
Not: whom do we want to dismiss? But: what will the organisation look like in future, and which jobs will it still need?
The restructuring toolbox
Restructuring does not automatically mean dismissal. Depending on the economic situation, time pressure, the number of employees affected, co-determination and the desired target structure, different instruments may be considered. The best solution often lies in a coordinated combination of several measures.
| 1 Economic goal | 2 Target organisation | 3 Staffing needs | 4 Mix of measures |
|---|---|---|---|
| Costs, capacities, sites | Tasks, functions, reporting lines | Positions, vacancies, comparison groups | Reorganisation, voluntary measures, dismissal |
1. Using natural turnover and cost measures
Not every cost reduction requires an active workforce reduction. Businesses should first check what relief can already be achieved through less drastic measures:
- Hiring freeze and not filling positions that become vacant
- Reducing temporary agency work and external resources
- Reducing overtime and voluntary additional benefits, where legally possible
- Reallocating or redistributing tasks
- Merging functions and removing unnecessary levels of hierarchy
These measures often take time but can considerably reduce the workforce reduction that later becomes necessary. Where the loss of work is merely temporary, short-time work (Kurzarbeit) may also be considered. Where the need for employees disappears permanently, by contrast, short-time work generally does not solve the structural problem.
2. Transfer and reorganisation instead of termination
If a specific job disappears, this does not necessarily mean that the employment relationship must also end. Options include in particular transfers, relocating or merging tasks, changed teams and reporting lines, a different place of work or taking on another vacant role.
Which change the employer can order unilaterally depends above all on the employment contract, the job description, collective agreements, works agreements and the scope of the right to issue instructions. If there is a suitable opportunity for continued employment, it must be examined before a termination is issued.
3. Dismissal with an offer of altered terms, when the work remains but the conditions do not
Sometimes the employment as such does not disappear. It simply can no longer continue on the previous terms. Typical cases are the relocation of a function to another site, the merging of tasks, the removal of a management level or a changed area of responsibility.
If the right to issue instructions is not sufficient and no consensual change to the contract can be achieved, a dismissal with an offer of altered terms (Änderungskündigung) may be considered. Beforehand, it must be checked whether the offer of change is limited to what is necessary and is reasonable for the employee.
4. Voluntary workforce reduction
Where a larger number of jobs is to disappear, voluntary solutions can be an alternative or a first stage before redundancy dismissals. A time-limited voluntary programme can provide in particular for severance payments, paid garden leave, early-exit bonuses, outplacement support and special solutions for employees close to retirement.
The advantage lies in planning certainty and avoiding numerous unfair dismissal proceedings. The challenge lies in control: a programme that is too open or too attractive can lead to precisely those employees leaving whose experience and qualifications are needed for the target organisation.
A voluntary programme should not just be a severance offer. It must specify in which functions reductions are needed and which skills must remain in the business.
5. Using termination agreements in a targeted way
Even without a company-wide voluntary programme, an individual termination agreement can make sense, for example for executives, long-serving employees, difficult social selection constellations, special protection against dismissal or increased litigation and reputational risk.
As a rule, it is not only the severance payment and termination date that need to be regulated, but also garden leave, holiday, variable remuneration, bonus, company car, work equipment, reference, post-contractual obligations and the final settlement of existing claims. Economically, what matters is the total cost and the legal certainty gained, not just the amount of the severance.
6. Redundancy dismissals
If organisational and voluntary measures are not sufficient, the redundancy dismissal remains an essential restructuring instrument. However, it requires an urgent operational need that precludes continued employment. A blanket reference to falling revenue or a savings target is not enough.
A robust plan should answer the following questions in particular:
- Which business decision was taken?
- What does the organisation look like before and after?
- Which tasks and jobs disappear permanently?
- Who takes over the remaining activities, and is their workload plausible?
- What other employment opportunities exist?
- Which employees are comparable with each other?
- How is the social selection carried out?
- Is there special protection against dismissal?
- Which participation rights of the works council must be observed?
7. Social selection and high performers
If only some employees from a group of comparable employees are affected, length of service, age, maintenance obligations and severe disability must be given appropriate consideration (social selection, Sozialauswahl). As a rule, only employees who can be deployed interchangeably on the basis of their contractual position and abilities are comparable.
However, the social selection does not necessarily have to result in employees who are particularly important for the future organisation leaving. Under the statutory conditions, employees can be excluded from the selection if their continued employment is in the legitimate interest of the business, in particular because of their knowledge, skills and performance or to secure a balanced staff structure. This exception should be justified concretely and documented.
8. Identifying special protection against dismissal early
Additional requirements may apply in particular to works council members, severely disabled persons, employees on parental leave or during statutory maternity protection. Required approvals or statutory prohibitions on dismissal can significantly affect the timetable and the choice of instruments. The groups of persons concerned should therefore not be identified only immediately before the dismissals are issued.
Restructuring with a works council
In larger restructurings, the collective law level becomes highly significant. It is not a formal point to be dealt with afterwards, but influences the timetable, costs, communication and room for manoeuvre of the entire project.
9. Operational change under Section 111 of the Works Constitution Act
In businesses with, as a rule, more than 20 employees entitled to vote, it must be checked at an early stage whether the planned measure constitutes an operational change (Betriebsänderung) within the meaning of Section 111 of the German Works Constitution Act (BetrVG). This can be the case in particular with the closure or downsizing of an establishment or significant parts of it, relocations, mergers or splits of establishments, and fundamental changes to the organisation, purpose or facilities of the establishment.
The employer must inform the works council about the planned operational change in good time and comprehensively and consult with it. If irreversible facts are created before the procedure has been properly carried out, there is a risk not only of delays but of additional claims.
10. Reconciliation of interests, social plan and compensation for disadvantages
The reconciliation of interests (Interessenausgleich) essentially concerns whether, when and how the planned operational change is carried out. The social plan (Sozialplan) serves to compensate for or mitigate the economic disadvantages that employees suffer as a result of the operational change.
The two instruments must be distinguished legally. A reconciliation of interests must be attempted but cannot be replaced by a ruling of the conciliation committee in the way that an enforceable social plan can. A social plan, by contrast, can be established by the conciliation committee under the statutory conditions. If the operational change consists solely of a workforce reduction, the special rules and thresholds of Section 112a BetrVG in particular must be observed for the enforceability of a social plan.
If a planned operational change is implemented without first sufficiently attempting a required reconciliation of interests, claims for compensation for disadvantages under Section 113 BetrVG may arise. The participation procedure should therefore be mapped in the project plan with clear decision points and communication rules.
11. Designing the social plan economically
A social plan is not just a severance table. It can combine severance payments, transfer measures, qualification, hardship provisions and support services. For employers, what matters is not only negotiating a severance factor but developing a viable overall architecture: what burden can the business bear, which groups of employees need which solution, and which elements promote swift implementation?
12. Transfer company and transfer measures
In larger workforce reductions, a transfer company can support the transition of affected employees into new employment. Under the conditions of Section 111 of Book III of the German Social Code (SGB III), transfer short-time allowance can be granted for a maximum of twelve months. For this purpose, the employees are generally grouped in an organisationally independent unit.
Particularly important for planning: the required advice from the Federal Employment Agency must take place before the decision on the use of transfer benefits. A transfer solution should therefore be included early in the negotiations on the reconciliation of interests and social plan. Transfer measures under Section 110 SGB III and transfer short-time allowance under Section 111 SGB III are different building blocks and must be examined separately.
13. Collective redundancy notification: the sequence is decisive
In larger workforce reductions, it must be checked at an early stage whether the thresholds of Section 17 of the German Protection Against Dismissal Act (KSchG) are reached. The decisive factors are, as a rule, the individual establishment and the number of dismissals planned within 30 calendar days.
| Regular employees in the establishment | Notification threshold within 30 calendar days |
|---|---|
| more than 20, fewer than 60 | more than 5 dismissals |
| at least 60, fewer than 500 | 10 % of regular employees or more than 25 dismissals |
| at least 500 | at least 30 dismissals |
If the procedure applies, the works council must be informed in writing and consulted in good time under Section 17 (2) KSchG. The consultation procedure and the notification to the Federal Employment Agency must be coordinated legally and in terms of timing. The required notification must have been validly made before the dismissals are issued.
The case law of the European Court of Justice of 30 October 2025 and the decisions of the Federal Labour Court (Bundesarbeitsgericht) building on it in 2026 have once again clearly underlined the importance of the procedure: a notification that was not made, or not validly made before the dismissal was issued, can render the dismissals concerned invalid. In the case of errors in content, a distinction must be made according to the nature and significance of the information concerned.
Other terminations initiated by the employer may also count. This must be examined in particular for termination agreements under a voluntary programme. The notification obligation therefore belongs at the start of the project and not on the checklist immediately before the dismissals are issued.
Sites, outsourcing and management level
14. Site closure and site relocation
Workforce reduction often reaches its greatest complexity when entire sites or parts of the business are affected. Transfer options, dismissals with altered terms, operational change, reconciliation of interests and social plan, collective redundancy law and, where applicable, transfer solutions then interlock.
First, it must be determined precisely what is to happen economically: closure, relocation, merger, sale or outsourcing. Under employment law, these variants can have different consequences.
15. Outsourcing, transfer of undertaking and carve-out
Restructuring does not take place solely within the same company. Typical measures are outsourcing logistics or IT, centralising shared services, relocating functions to other group companies, selling a business unit or separating a part of the business as part of a carve-out.
It must then be examined at an early stage whether a transfer of an undertaking or part of an undertaking under Section 613a of the German Civil Code (BGB) may exist. Corporate structure, transaction and employment law must reflect the same target picture. Merely relabelling something as “outsourcing” does not prevent the statutory consequences of a transfer of undertaking.
16. Management and executives
Restructurings often also affect the management level. For managing directors, the dismissal from office under corporate law and the termination of the service agreement must be examined separately. In addition, remuneration, bonus, garden leave, D&O insurance, non-compete obligations and directors’ liability can continue to have an effect.
For senior executives and other managers, it must also be clarified whether tasks are disappearing, areas of responsibility are changing or an amicable separation makes more economic sense. It is precisely here that employment law combines with corporate and contract law.
The typical mistakes
- Person instead of position: The business decides early on who should go, before the future organisation has been determined.
- Unclear target organisation: The disappearance of tasks, remaining tasks and their future allocation are not documented robustly.
- Communicating too early: Measures are communicated as decided although participation and negotiation processes are still open.
- Looking only at severance: Notice periods, garden leave, bonus, transfer costs and litigation risks are left out of the budget.
- Voluntary programme without control: Key skill holders leave while employees in functions to be reduced stay.
- Not examining continued employment: Vacant positions and reasonable alternatives are identified too late.
- Recognising special protection too late: Required approvals or prohibitions on dismissal jeopardise the timetable.
- Implementing an operational change prematurely: Reconciliation of interests, social plan and possible claims for compensation for disadvantages are underestimated.
- Checking Section 17 KSchG only at the end: Termination agreements and dismissals are planned without properly calculating the 30-day window and the establishment reference.
- Viewing employment law in isolation: Site relocations, outsourcing and carve-outs are structured without planning the employment law consequences.
Seven questions before starting a restructuring
- Can you set out the future organisation and explain which functions and positions will no longer be needed there?
- Do you know the number of positions that actually have to disappear, or is there only a general cost target so far?
- Have you examined what part of the reduction can be achieved through turnover, a hiring freeze, transfers or voluntary solutions?
- Do you know which employees are comparable and where special protection against dismissal or opportunities for continued employment exist?
- Is the measure an operational change, and when must the works council be involved?
- Could a reconciliation of interests, social plan, transfer solution or collective redundancy notification become necessary?
- Besides severance, have you budgeted for notice periods, garden leave, variable remuneration, transfer costs and litigation risks?
If you do not yet have a robust answer on several points, the restructuring should first be structured before individual personnel measures are initiated. This phase generally offers the greatest room for manoeuvre.
Restructuring support for mid-sized businesses
We support restructurings from the company’s perspective: from the legal structuring of the target picture and the selection of suitable instruments to implementation vis-à-vis employees and the works council.
- Review and structuring of the restructuring concept
- Legal mapping of the target organisation
- Transfer and continued employment concepts
- Voluntary programmes and termination agreements
- Redundancy dismissals and dismissals with altered terms
- Social selection and special protection against dismissal
- Reconciliation of interests, social plan and conciliation committee
- Collective redundancy notification and transfer solutions
- Site closure, site relocation and outsourcing
- Separation from managing directors and executives
Our approach is not to issue dismissals as quickly as possible. We translate the economic goal into a legally robust implementation structure and compare the available instruments by cost, speed and legal risk.
Talk to us.
Frequently asked questions
No. Depending on the situation, a hiring freeze, natural turnover, transfers, reorganisation, termination agreements or voluntary programmes can achieve part of the required adjustment.
Fundamentally, there must be an urgent operational need that precludes continued employment. In addition, other employment opportunities and, where applicable, the social selection must be examined.
That can make sense but is not a blanket recommendation. Voluntary solutions create planning certainty but must be controlled so that the skills needed in the target organisation are retained.
In the case of an operational change under Sections 111 et seq. BetrVG, the participation of the works council may be required. Whether a social plan is enforceable depends on the statutory conditions; for a pure workforce reduction, Section 112a BetrVG in particular must be observed.
When the thresholds of Section 17 KSchG, which are staggered by size of establishment, are reached within 30 calendar days. Termination agreements initiated by the employer may count towards them.
The overall budget generally covers more than severance payments: possible items include remuneration during notice periods, garden leave, variable remuneration, transfer measures, social plan benefits and the costs of labour court disputes.
Ideally already when the target organisation is being developed. The earlier the consequences under employment law, works constitution law and corporate law are taken into account, the greater the room for manoeuvre remains.
This article provides a general overview for information purposes only and does not replace advice on individual cases. As of: 25 October 2026.